COURT EVENTS, PROGRAMS, AND COMMUNITY OUTREACH
Special Events
Court Honors Volunteers during National Pro Bono Celebration Week
On October 24, 2013, the Court honored pro bono volunteers in the district with a celebration and reception at the Edward R. Roybal Federal Building and U.S. Courthouse in Los Angeles as part of National Pro Bono Celebration Week. National Pro Bono Celebration Week, held on the third week of October, is promoted by the American Bar Association’s Standing Committee on Pro Bono and Public Service. Every October since 2011, the Court has participated by publishing an Honor Roll which names volunteers at the pro bono organizations that serve each of the Court’s five divisions. In 2013, the Court’s Pro Se Committee added to the tradition by hosting its first celebration. In addition to being published on the Court’s website, the 2013 Honor Roll and 2012 Pro Se Annual Report were shared at the event, and certificates of appreciation for each of the pro bono volunteers were awarded. Chief Judge Peter H. Carroll spoke at the gathering and emphasized the positive impact pro bono volunteers have on the Court’s self-represented filers, who continue to account for approximately one quarter of total filings, even as the number of total filings decreases. Pro Se Committee Chair Judge Maureen A. Tighe and Judges Catherine E. Bauer, Julia W. Brand, Thomas B. Donovan, Sandra R. Klein, and Vincent P. Zurzolo expressed their thanks to the volunteers.
Calvin Ashland Awards Dinner
On November 14, 2013, the Central District Consumer Bankruptcy Attorney Association (cdcbaa) hosted the largest-ever Calvin Ashland Awards Dinner at the L.A. Hotel Downtown. Chief Judge Peter H. Carroll, Judges Ernest M. Robles, Maureen A. Tighe, Theodor C. Albert, Robert N. Kwan, Scott C. Clarkson, Sandra R. Klein, and Neil W. Bason, Executive Officer/Clerk of Court Kathleen J. Campbell, and U.S. Trustee Peter Anderson were among the crowd of 170 in attendance.
In his speech, Chief Judge Peter H. Carroll recognized cdcbaa’s extraordinary efforts in supporting the Debtor Assistance Project (DAP) and pro bono organizations. Public Counsel attorneys Magdalena Reyes Bordeaux and Christian Cooper joined him to accept a check for the proceeds from cdcbaa’s Fifth Annual Earle Hagen Memorial Golf Tournament. The 2013 event raised $29,231.35 for the DAP, bringing the total amount the event has raised over the past five years to more than $130,000.
Additionally, Jeffrey Golden was named Trustee of the Year for 2013. Mr. Golden is the first chapter 7 Trustee to win the award. Bankruptcy attorney Jim King received the Founder’s Lifetime Achievement Award for his efforts in support of the consumer bar, the Court, Public Counsel Law Center’s Debtor Assistance Project (DAP), and pro bono organizations.
2013 William J. Lasarow Awards
On November 21, 2013, Public Counsel, one of the nation’s largest pro bono law firms, hosted the annual William J. Lasarow Awards ceremony in the Edward R. Roybal Federal Building and U.S. Courthouse in Los Angeles. Public Counsel hosted the annual awards ceremony and reception to recognize volunteers serving the pro se bankruptcy population throughout the Central District of California.
For the 12-month period ending September 30, 2013, the Central District led the nation in pro se filings with 21,097, representing over 21 percent of all pro se filings nationally. The Central District’s pro se filing rate of 25.5 percent is nearly three times the national average of 8.8 percent. Without the services of the pro bono volunteers who staff the Self-Help Desks in each of the five divisions, self-represented parties would not receive essential guidance on bankruptcy law and advice on how best to obtain an effective resolution to their cases.
Retired Bankruptcy Judge William J. Lasarow, District Judge George H. Wu, and Bankruptcy Judges Vincent P. Zurzolo, Thomas B. Donovan, Maureen A. Tighe, Richard M. Neiter, Robert N. Kwan, Catherine E. Bauer, Sandra R. Klein, Julia W. Brand, and Neil W. Bason were joined by over 100 guests at the gala. Senior Staff Attorney Magdalena Reyes Bordeaux and Public Counsel President and CEO Hernán Vera opened the ceremony, followed by Judge Zurzolo, who congratulated all the volunteers and noted the significance of receiving a distinguished award in Judge Lasarow’s name. Judge Zurzolo also noted that despite a decline in the number of filings in the Central District, the percentage of pro se filings remains steady at over a quarter of total filings, underscoring the continued need for volunteers to assist self-represented parties.
Each of the five organizations operating Self-Help Desks in the Central District honored an outstanding volunteer during 2013. The honorees were: Jim King, Carissa Horowitz, Scott Talkov, Leslie Keith Kaufman, and Anil Bhartia. The combined efforts of these volunteers were instrumental in helping the Court improve access to justice and service to the public during 2013.
Judge Barry Russell Annual Scholarship Awards
The 31st Annual Judge Barry Russell Scholarship Awards were presented at the Biltmore Hotel in Los Angeles on October 3, 2013. Every year, each ABA-accredited law school in the Los Angeles area selects a student who has done outstanding work in the area of federal courts and practice to receive the award. The five recipients for 2013 were: Katherine Cheng, UCLA Law School; Nicholas Mitchell, Southwestern Law School; Ashley Kaplan, USC Law School; Olga Novak, Loyola Law School; and Kelsey Halverson, Pepperdine Law School. Winners of the award received a plaque, signed copy of Judge Russell’s Bankruptcy Evidence Manual, and $500 check.
Judge Scott C. Clarkson Honors John F. Kennedy on 50th Anniversary of Assassination
On November 22, 2013, the 50th anniversary of President John F. Kennedy’s assassination, Judge Scott C. Clarkson screened President Kennedy’s 1961 inaugural address in a special court session. The session was designed as an opportunity to reflect upon the policies and accomplishments of Kennedy’s brief 34-month term as president of the United States. Approximately 60 people attended the program, including federal judges, attorneys, and members of the Court staff and public.
Bankruptcy Judges Preside over Naturalization Ceremonies
Nine bankruptcy judges from the Central District presided over naturalization ceremonies in 2013. Chief Judge Peter H. Carroll and Judges Barry Russell, Maureen A. Tighe, Robert N. Kwan, Catherine E. Bauer, Scott C. Clarkson, Sandra R. Klein, Neil W. Bason, and Mark D. Houle each led the swearing in of new citizens in ceremonies throughout the year at the Los Angeles Convention Center, Pomona Fairplex, Quiet Cannon, and National Orange Show Events Center.
OCBF and the Commercial Law and Bankruptcy Law Section Recognize Pro Bono Volunteers
On December 3, 2013, the Orange County Bankruptcy Forum (OCBF) and the Commercial Law and Bankruptcy Section of the Orange County Bar Association (OCBA) hosted their annual holiday party recognizing the efforts of the volunteers in the pro bono clinic. Speakers included Santa Ana Judges Theodor C. Albert and Catherine E. Bauer; Chair of OCBA’s Commercial Law and Bankruptcy Section, Richard Marshack; Immediate Past Chair of OCBA’s Commercial Law and Bankruptcy Section, Anerio Altman; Vice Chair of OCBA’s Commercial Law and Bankruptcy Section Leigh Ferrin; and OCBF President Beth Gaschen. The Santa Ana Clerk’s Office was also recognized by the attorneys and judges present at the event for their contributions to the pro bono clinic.
Speaking Engagements and Programs
Judge Sheri Bluebond Participates in Financial Lawyers Conference
On January 10, 2013, Judge Sheri Bluebond took part in a panel discussion sponsored by the Financial Lawyers Conference. The discussion, “Don’t Be Cruel: Cramdown Issues Affecting Classes of Unsecured Creditors,” examined the scarcity of case law addressing the issues that arise when a dissenting class of unsecured creditors opposes a plan. Judge Bluebond and panelists Scott F. Gautier, Esq., and Justin E. Rawlins, Esq., discussed the recent decisions regarding cramdown-related issues.
"An Evening with Our Judges" in Riverside
Judges Meredith A. Jury, Deborah J. Saltzman, Mark S. Wallace, Scott C. Clarkson, Wayne Johnson, and Mark D. Houle served as panelists at the Inland Empire Bankruptcy Forum’s annual dinner and meeting on January 15, 2013 at the Hyatt Place Hotel in Riverside. The judges shared their thoughts on a variety of matters that have come to their attention while on the bench such as the initial client meeting, ethical matters, abusive filings, chapter 13 matters, and other matters arising in chapter 11 cases.
Judge Catherine E. Bauer Participates in Panel Discussion at OCBF Program
On January 17, 2013, Judge Catherine E. Bauer attended the Orange County Bankruptcy Forum’s (OCBF) Brown Bag Program at the Ronald Reagan Federal Building and U.S. Courthouse in Santa Ana. Judge Bauer was a panelist in the program’s “What Do You Mean ‘No Proof of Service’?” discussion regarding the implementation of new local rules.
Judges Tighe and Zive Participate in ABI Inaugural Western Consumer Bankruptcy Conference
The American Bankruptcy Institute's Inaugural Western Consumer Conference was a day-long program held on January 21, 2013 in Las Vegas, Nevada. Designed for consumer bankruptcy practitioners, the program addressed topics that consumer practitioners needed most: individual chapter 11’s, the latest on mortgages, and ethics. Judge Maureen A. Tighe served on the Planning Committee for the event and participated as a moderator on the “Ethics: Representation Issues: Don’t Gamble with your Reputation or Getting Paid” panel. Additionally, Judge Gregg W. Zive moderated the “Evidence: What It Is, Why You Need It, and How to Get It Admitted” panel.
Judge Barry Russell Speaks on Motions to Dismiss
On January 22, 2013, Judge Barry Russell and attorneys Howard M. Ehrenberg and Stella A. Havkin hosted a lunch at the San Fernando Valley Bar Association in Tarzana. Judge Russell and the attorneys discussed motions to dismiss.
Clerk's Office Staff Speaks at NALS Meeting
On February 13, 2013, Clerk’s Office staff members Cynthia Beezer and Tina Duarte attended the Orange County Chapter’s National Association of Legal Secretaries (NALS) meeting to discuss updates to the Local Rules and changes in the requirements of the Notice of Lodgment and proof of service documents. They also discussed how the judges’ courtesy copies should be packaged and delivered.
Judge Julia W. Brand Joins Panel Discussion on Section 363
On February 19, 2013, Judge Julia W. Brand participated in a panel discussion on “Recent Developments Affecting Section 363 Bankruptcy Sales and Sale Orders,” sponsored by the Bankruptcy Law Section of the Beverly Hills Bar Association. Judge Brand, joined attorneys Jeff N. Pomerantz, a partner at Pachulski, Stang, Ziehl, Young & Jones, LLP, and John N. Tedford IV, a partner at Danning, Gill, Diamond & Kollitz, LLP. Rebecca J. Winthrop, of counsel at Fulbright & Jaworski LLP, moderated the discussion. The one-hour program presented issues that arise in sales under section 363 of the Bankruptcy Code and recent case law developments.
Judge Wayne Johnson Sponsors Brown Bag Lunches
On February 20 and November 27, 2013, Judge Wayne Johnson sponsored brown bag lunches in his courtroom for the Inland Empire Bar to provide participants with the opportunity to ask questions about policies and procedures.
Judge Mark S. Wallace Speaks at Valcon 2013
On February 21, 2013, Judge Mark S. Wallace spoke at the American Bankruptcy Institute’s “Valcon 2013: Contested Valuation Issues in Bankruptcy,” held at the Four Seasons Hotel in Las Vegas, Nevada. Judge Wallace took part in the panel discussion “Valuation, Restructuring and Taxes: The Good, the Bad and the Ugly” with Steven J. Joffe, Senior Managing Director of FTI Consulting. The discussion, moderated by Robert Liquerman, Esq., examined topics related to the effect of restructuring on tax attributes.
Judges Albert and Clarkson Participate in Stern v. Marshall Discussion
On February 26, 2013, Judge Theodor C. Albert and Judge Scott C. Clarkson served as panelists in an Orange County Bankruptcy Forum discussion regarding the theoretical and practical implications of In re Bellingham Insurance Agency, Inc. and other authorities following Stern v. Marshall, 131 S. Ct. 2594 (2011). The event was held at the Westin South Coast Plaza in Costa Mesa.
Judge Mark S. Wallace Speaks at USC School of Law Forum
On March 7, 2013, Judge Mark S. Wallace took part in a panel discussion at the USC Gould School of Law’s 2013 Real Estate Law and Business Forum held at the Jonathan Club in Los Angeles. Attorney John Schafer moderated the “Real Estate Lessons from the Bankruptcy Courts: What Developers and Attorneys Should Know before Closing the Next Big Deal” discussion.
Law Clerks Participate in Riverside Panel Discussion
On March 12, 2013, approximately 60 members of the legal community participated in “An Evening with the Judges’ Law Clerks: What They Want You to Know about Getting it Right the First Time.” Topics included notice/service issues, orders, notice of lodgment, emergency motion procedures, and local rules. The event was sponsored by the Inland Empire Bankruptcy Forum and held at the Hyatt Place in Riverside. Law Clerks Andrew Minear (Judge Meredith A. Jury), James Behrens (Judge Deborah J. Saltzman), and Jorge Gaitan (Judge Mark D. Houle) led the discussion with the assistance of Elizabeth A. Larocque, Esq., from Goe & Forsythe, LLP, who organized and moderated the event. The program was well-received, and attendees stated that the panel was informative and entertaining.
Chief Judge Peter H. Carroll Speaks at "State of the Circuit/District" Luncheon
On March 14, 2013, the Los Angeles Chapter of the Federal Bar Association hosted its annual “State of the Circuit/District” luncheon at the DoubleTree Hotel in downtown Los Angeles. The event featured Senior Circuit Judge A. Wallace Tashima, Chief District Judge George H. King, Chief Magistrate Judge Suzanne H. Segal, and Chief Bankruptcy Judge Peter H. Carroll. Over 200 judges, attorneys, and law clerks were in attendance.
During the luncheon, each of the four judges discussed the current state of his or her court, commenting on issues such as budget concerns, newly appointed judges, new and ongoing programs, and strategic plans for the future. The impact of sequestration was discussed by all, and Chief Judge King made an impassioned appeal to attendees to take action to preserve and protect the federal courts.
Chief Bankruptcy Judge Peter H. Carroll reported on the state of the Bankruptcy Court. He noted that the Central District continued to lead the nation in bankruptcy filings, despite a 30 percent drop from last year. He stated that no new bankruptcy judges have been added since February 2012, despite the fact that each judge continues to handle about 1700 weighted cases—200 more than the national average. Chief Judge Carroll added that with the drop in filings and sequestration, the Bankruptcy Court's funding had been reduced by about $2.6 million since October 1, 2012. Additionally, he noted the Court dealt with the cuts by streamlining procedures, offering early retirements, and implementing staff reductions. Chief Judge Carroll specified that given these changes, he is focusing, developing, and implementing the Court's strategic plan to respond to the changes expected over the next decade. He also commented that the task is especially important given the challenges posed by the present economy. Since this luncheon, the Court has published its Strategic Plan, which defines the Court’s direction for the next five years.
At the conclusion of the luncheon, Chief Judge Carroll was presented with a framed copy of his judicial profile written by attorney Christie L. Cronenweth, and published in the January-February edition of The Federal Lawyer.
Judges Clarkson and Zive Speak at ABI's "Bankruptcy Battleground West"
On March 22, 2013, seasoned insolvency professionals discussed, debated, and learned about leading issues of bankruptcy law at the American Bankruptcy Institute’s “Bankruptcy Battleground West.” The program offered concurrent sessions on commercial bankruptcy topics.
Judge Scott C. Clarkson, Judicial Chair, participated in the concurrent session “Current Topics in Bankruptcy Litigation (Trying Cases in Trying Times without Trying Your Judge’s Patience).” This session explored litigation trends, strategies, and alternative theories of recovery reflective of the need to focus on litigation in the absence of traditional reorganization. Participants picked up some helpful trial tips and practice pointers, including identifying causes of action, choosing your jurisdiction, engaging professionals, preparing experts, and organizing for trial.
Judge Gregg W. Zive participated in the New Ninth Circuit Chapter 11 Plan Confirmation Developments. This panel explored recent developments in several Ninth Circuit chapter 11 plan cases, from contested new-value plans and interest rate valuations in the cramdown context to section 1111(b) elections, designating votes, plan mootness and dealing with the reversal of plan confirmation orders, classification, and ways to maximize the value of the estate post-confirmation.
Judge Vincent P. Zurzolo Participates in "Stay Away from the Dark Side: Ethical Pitfalls in Bankruptcy" Discussion
On April 1, 2013, Judge Vincent P. Zurzolo, joined by Hatty Yip from the Office of the U.S. Trustee, Martin R. Barash from Klee Tuchin Bogdanoff & Stern LLP, and Uzzi O. Raanan from Danning Gill Diamond & Kollitz LLP served as panelists in the Los Angeles Bankruptcy Forum’s “Stay Away from the Dark Side: Avoiding Ethical Pitfalls in Bankruptcy” program. A lively discussion ensued on issues such as conflicts of interest, breach of ethical requirements, disqualification from representation, and sanctions. The program was held at the L.A. Hotel Downtown in Los Angeles.
Judges Jury and Zive Address ABI 31st Annual Spring Meeting Attendees
Judges Meredith A. Jury and Gregg W. Zive attended the American Bankruptcy Institute’s (ABI) 31st Annual Spring Meeting held from April 18 to April 21, 2013. Judge Jury was a panelist in the concurrent session “Chapter 11 Track: Chapter 9s, Nonprofits and Other Nontraditional Restructuring Processes.” The panelists discussed the financial crisis and its toll on municipalities as evidenced by the increasing number of chapter 9 petitions over the last two years. This panel also explored cutting-edge issues involved in these and other nontraditional restructuring processes. Judge Zive participated as a panelist for the concurrent session entitled “Chapter 11 Track: The Section 1111(b) Election, Plan Feasibility and Cramdown Issues.” This session utilized a case study to explore issues surrounding a lender’s decision on whether or not to make an election under Section 1111(b), feasibility issues, voting issues, and solid mathematical analysis.
Judge Sandra R. Klein Participates in "Thinking Like a New Federal Judge" Discussion
On April 18, 2013, the Los Angeles Chapter of the Federal Bar Association held its newest program, “Thinking Like a New Federal Judge.” The program was hosted by O’Melveny & Myers, moderated by Loyola Law Professor Laurie L. Levenson, and featured four newly appointed federal judges, all of whom shared their experiences and gave tips about successful advocacy in their respective courts.
Judge Sandra R. Klein described the process of being selected as a bankruptcy judge. She also discussed the merit screening committee process and her interview by four circuit judges and one chief bankruptcy judge from a different district. Judge Klein highlighted some of the particular challenges bankruptcy courts face such as the lack of court-provided interpreters.
Judge Scott C. Clarkson Speaks at NACBA 21st Annual Convention
On April 27, 2013, the National Association of Consumer Bankruptcy Attorneys (NACBA) held its 21st Annual Convention at the Manchester Grand Hyatt in San Diego. Judge Scott C. Clarkson served as a panelist for the “Exploring Individual Chapter 11” group session.
Judge Julia W. Brand Participates in "A Review of the Ninth Circuit Bankruptcy Decisions 2012" Discussion
Judge Julia W. Brand served on the “A Review of Ninth Circuit Bankruptcy Decisions 2012” video presentation panel on May 1, 2013. The discussion, hosted by the Ninth Circuit Bankruptcy Judges Education Committee, Ninth Circuit Executive’s Office, and the Federal Judicial Center, included Bankruptcy Judges Brian D. Lynch from the Western District of Washington and Patricia C. Williams from the Eastern District of Washington.
Judge Mark S. Wallace Participates in "Judges' Perspective: What Tax Practitioners Need to Know about Chapter 11" Discussion
On May 10, 2013, Judge Mark S. Wallace attended the American Bar Association’s Section of Taxation meeting in Washington, D.C. The meeting was held to analyze the latest federal tax policy, initiatives, regulations, legislative forecasts, and planning ideas developed by the country’s leading tax attorneys and government officials. Judge Wallace participated in the panel “Judges’ Perspective: What Tax Practitioners Need to Know about Chapter 11.”
Central District Judges Participate in 25th Annual Insolvency Conference
From May 17 to May 19, 2013, Chief Judge Peter H. Carroll and Judges Alan M. Ahart, Vincent P. Zurzolo, Erithe A. Smith, Sheri Bluebond, Maureen A. Tighe, Theodor C. Albert, Victoria S. Kaufman, Robert N. Kwan, Catherine E. Bauer, Scott C. Clarkson, Sandra R. Klein, Julia W. Brand, and Neil W. Bason attended the California Bankruptcy Forum’s 25th Annual Insolvency Conference in San Diego.
On May 17, Judge Klein served on the “Beverly Hills Cop-Issues in Parallel Criminal, Bankruptcy, and Forfeiture Proceedings” panel. The discussion explained the impact of sentencing, forfeiture proceedings and restitution on civil discovery and the competing interests of the bankruptcy estate and government as to asset ownership. In addition, Judge Clarkson participated in the “Wall Street – Effective Use of Financial Consultants and Experts in Chapter 11” panel. The discussion addressed the use of financial consultants in providing critical financial analyses to fulfill reporting requirements and support the essential motions and proceedings required in successful chapter 11 cases, as well as the role of the expert in bankruptcy litigation generally.
On May 18, a number of judges participated in panel discussions. Judges Ahart, Albert, Kaufman, Kwan, Clarkson, and Brand joined the “Forum Feud” panel, hosted by Judge Bluebond. Also, keynote speaker Judge Bason and participating Judges Zurzolo, Smith, Bauer, and Brand addressed professional development and career advancement during the Young Insolvency Program (YIP) roundtable luncheon. In his keynote address, Judge Bason shared personal stories about his professional achievements and discussed tips and techniques for career growth and development. In addition, Judge Tighe served on “The Evil Dead – Identifying and Dealing Effectively with Violations of the Automatic Stay and Discharge Orders” panel. The discussion addressed protecting creditor clients from sanctions and getting paid to protect debtors from creditors who will not relent after debtors are presumed dead. Later, Judge Clarkson participated in the “Raiders of the Lost Ark – Identifying Estate Interests in Atypical Property” discussion. The panel aided the participants in determining which interests are a “trustee’s treasure” and which interests are not the property of the estate. Judge Ahart concluded with a discussion on the California homestead and other exemptions, including missed and misapplied exemptions and recent case law on exemption application and defense strategies, as a member of the “Nightmare on Elm Street—Will Debtors Be Able to Keep Homestead Exemption Proceeds?” panel.
Chief Judge Peter H. Carroll served as the Judicial Liaison for the conference. Chief Judge Carroll and Judge Tighe also served as members of the California Bankruptcy Forum's task force assigned to develop and implement a Pro Bono Project for the forum.
Judge Scott C. Clarkson Participates in "Chapter 11 Tactics of Secured and Unsecured Lenders: Creditor Proposed Plans of Reorganization" Discussion
On May 21, 2013, Judge Scott C. Clarkson attended the Orange County Bar Association’s Banking and Lending Section’s May meeting. Judge Clarkson, joined by attorneys Nanette D. Sanders and Christopher L. Blank, discussed “Chapter 11 Tactics of Secured and Unsecured Lenders: Creditor Proposed Plans of Reorganization.”
Judge Sheri Bluebond Speaks at 2013 Journalist Law School
On May 30, 2013, Judge Sheri Bluebond moderated a judges’ panel discussion at the 2013 Journalist Law School, an annual four-day intensive seminar at Loyola Law School for journalists who report on the legal system. In the discussion, “The Courts’ Perspective: A Panel Discussion with the California State Federal Judicial Council,” District Judge Dale S. Fischer, Justice Nora M. Manella of the California Court of Appeal, and Superior Court Judge Brian C. Walsh addressed topics including judicial ethics, cameras in the court, access to juror questionnaires and other court documents, and common misconceptions.
Judge Maureen A. Tighe Addresses the San Fernando Valley Bar Association
On May 30, 2013, Judge Maureen A. Tighe discussed section 523(a) adversary cases at the San Fernando Valley Bar Association in Reseda.
Judge Mark S. Wallace Speaks at 29th Annual Bankruptcy and Restructuring Conference
On June 5, 2013, Judge Mark S. Wallace addressed the Association of Insolvency and Restructuring Advisors’ 29th Annual Bankruptcy and Restructuring Conference in Chicago, Illinois. Judge Wallace discussed the use of liquidating trusts in bankruptcy cases and the taxation of liquidating trusts.
Strategic Plan Presented to cdcbaa
On June 22, 2013, the Strategic Planning Committee presented a draft of the Strategic Plan at a Central District Consumer Bankruptcy Attorney Association (cdcbaa) meeting held at Southwestern Law School. Chief Judge Peter H. Carroll, Judges Maureen A. Tighe, Deborah J. Saltzman, Scott C. Clarkson, and Sandra R. Klein, Executive Officer/Clerk of Court Kathleen J. Campbell, and members of the Clerk’s Office staff described different aspects of the Strategic Plan. The presentation focused on the five issues in the draft of the Court’s Strategic Plan: Administration of Justice; Access to Justice and Service to the Public; Judiciary Workforce of the Future; A Solid Infrastructure; and Public Understanding, Trust, and Confidence. The presentation was followed by a question and answer session.
Judge Sandra R. Klein Discusses "An Introduction to Adversary Proceedings"
On July 11, 2013, Public Counsel hosted “An Introduction to Adversary Proceedings” at the Edward R. Roybal Federal Building and U.S. Courthouse in Los Angeles.
The program focused on providing attorneys who have never handled an adversary proceeding with an introductory overview of bringing and defending an adversary proceeding. The panel included Judge Sandra R. Klein, Attorney Roksana D. Moradi of Simon Resnick Hayes, and Attorney Roye Zur of Landau Gottfried & Berger.
Judge Scott C. Clarkson Speaks at Bench and Bar Lunch Meeting
On July 24, 2013, Judge Scott C. Clarkson addressed the Orange County Federal Bar Association on the power of tolerating ambiguity in legal practice. During his presentation, Judge Clarkson reminded the crowd that comfort with the unknown and an appetite for knowledge are undervalued signs of leadership. Drawing upon examples of creative problem solving, the judge emphasized the importance of understanding a problem before attempting to solve it.
Judges Russell, Smith, and Zive Participate in ABI Annual Southwest Bankruptcy Conference
From August 22 through August 24, 2013, American Bankruptcy Institute (ABI) hosted the 21st Annual Southwest Bankruptcy Conference in Incline Village, Nevada. Judge Barry Russell participated in the “Judicial Debate” session. He argued that claims benefiting from third-party guaranties may be separately classified, while Judge Eileen W. Hollowell of the U.S. Bankruptcy Court, District of Arizona argued the contrary.
Judge Erithe A. Smith participated in the “Current Developments in Chapter 11” session. The panel discussed a wide range of issues ranging from bankruptcy courts’ jurisdiction, venue, and constitutional authority, to other practical issues affecting estate professionals, plan confirmation and enforcement, avoidance actions, and other bankruptcy-related litigation. Judge Gregg W. Zive participated in the “Ethics: Disagreeing without Being Disagreeable: The Case for Civility” session. This panel explored the struggles of being both civil and persuasive, and how actions affect the reputation of the legal profession in society. The panel provided an update on the status of the ABI Civility Task Force.
Judge Thomas B. Donovan Participates in BHBA Program
On September 12, 2013, Judge Thomas B. Donovan was a panelist in the Beverly Hills Bar Association (BHBA) program, “Nuts & Bolts of Bankruptcy.” Judge Donovan, joined by attorneys Elizabeth Z. Jiang and Zev Shechtman, addressed the fundamental concepts about bankruptcy that every lawyer should know. In addition, the panel discussed claims, property of the estate, bankruptcy discharge, and common pitfalls and practice tips.
Judge Catherine E. Bauer Speaks at Chief Bankruptcy Judges Meeting
On September 13, 2013, Judge Catherine E. Bauer, a member of the Ninth Circuit's Pro Se Committee, spoke at the Chief Bankruptcy Judges meeting in San Diego regarding the new bankruptcy-related pro se section of the Ninth Circuit's website. The website provides available resources related to the various programs, such as legal clinics and reaffirmation counseling that are available for self-represented parties throughout the Circuit, and points of contact at each court.
Judge Ernest M. Robles Speaks at cdcbaa
On September 21, 2013, Judge Ernest M. Robles presented at the Central District Consumer Bankruptcy Attorney Association (cdcbaa) meeting on the topic of “Litigation in Bankruptcy Court.” The event was attended by top practitioners from the creditor and debtor bar, judges, members of the court staff, bankruptcy trustees, and other bankruptcy professionals.
Judge Mark S. Wallace Discusses "Assisting Clients with Student Loan Issues"
On September 28, 2013, Judge Mark S. Wallace was a speaker at the “Assisting Clients With Student Loan Debt Issues” seminar, hosted by the Commercial Law and Bankruptcy Section of the Orange County Bar Association at the Radisson Hotel in Newport Beach. The seminar covered an array of topics, including: “Dealing with Student Loans and Lenders,” “Remedies under the FDCPA,” “Student Loans in Bankruptcy—Current Status of Dischargeability under the Bankruptcy Code,” and “Tips and Strategies to Build Expertise in This Growing Practice Area.”
"Judges' Night: Differing Perspectives on Legal Issues"
On October 1, 2013, Chief Judge Peter H. Carroll and Judges Erithe A. Smith, Theodor C. Albert, Richard M. Neiter, Catherine E. Bauer, Deborah J. Saltzman, Mark S. Wallace, Scott C. Clarkson, and Mark D. Houle participated in the Orange County Bankruptcy Forum’s “Judges' Night: Differing Perspectives on Legal Issues.” The event, moderated by attorney Jess Bressi, was held at the Westin South Coast Plaza in Costa Mesa.
Judge Barry Russell Participates in "Objection Your Honor!" Workshop
On October 19, 2013, Judge Barry Russell was a speaker at the Orange County Bankruptcy Forum’s “Objection Your Honor!” program, held at Chapman University School of Law. The workshop discussed evidentiary issues arising at all stages of bankruptcy cases and adversary proceedings. The interactive program focused on how to get evidence admitted and make effective objections. In addition to valuable practice tips from the distinguished panelists, participants reviewed the rules of evidence.
Judges Speak to Law Students about Externship Opportunities in the Federal Courts
On October 21, 2013, more than 100 eager law students attended a federal judicial externship panel hosted by Loyola Law School. The event was designed to inform students about the nature of externship programs in the federal courts and the hiring process. The panel featured three federal judges from the Central District of California: Bankruptcy Judge Sandra R. Klein, District Judge Beverly Reid O’Connell, and Chief Magistrate Judge Suzanne H. Segal. The judges were joined by Angella D. Yates, Law Clerk to Bankruptcy Judge Neil W. Bason and mentor for Loyal Law School students seeking judicial externships and clerkships.
Judges Participate in the IEBF Twentieth Annual Survey of Consumer Bankruptcy Law
On October 26, 2013, Judges Meredith A. Jury, Deborah J. Saltzman, Mark S. Wallace, and Mark D. Houle were panelists at the Inland Empire Bankruptcy Forum’s (IEBF) Twentieth Annual Survey of Consumer Bankruptcy Law. Moderated by attorney Arnold H. Wuhrman, the panelists presented a survey of recent cases affecting consumer bankruptcy practice, with an emphasis on decisions of the U.S. Supreme Court, the Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals, the Bankruptcy Appellate Panel of the Ninth Circuit, and California district and bankruptcy courts.
Judges Bluebond and Klein Provide Training for Los Angeles Superior Court Judges
On November 5, 2013, Judges Sheri Bluebond and Sandra R. Klein provided training for Los Angeles Superior Court judges. Judge Bluebond presented “When Worlds Collide: Bankruptcy and its Impact on Domestic Relations and Family Law” to family law judges. Judge Klein presented “Bankruptcy: Everything You Wanted to Know But Did Not Know Who to Ask” to civil judges.
Judges Bluebond, Klein, and Zive Attend 25th Annual ABI Leadership Conference
From December 5 through December 7, 2013, Judges Sheri Bluebond, Sandra R. Klein, and Gregg W. Zive attended the American Bankruptcy Institute’s 25th Annual Winter Leadership Conference in Rancho Palos Verdes. Judge Bluebond participated in a panel on “Plan Support Agreements/Pre-Arranged Cases" that included practitioners from across the Judge Sheri Bluebond country. Judge Bluebond’s panel discussed the use of plan support agreements, their impact on non-signatories, disclosure and solicitation issues, lessons learned from recent cases, and the applicability of plan support agreements in middle-market cases. Judge Klein, joined by Chief Circuit Judge Alex Kozinski, Judge Eugene R. Wedoff of the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Northern District of Illinois, and Judge Gregg W. Zive of the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the District of Nevada, discussed the “Do’s and Don’ts of Written Advocacy” and provided guidance for effective and persuasive written advocacy.
Tenth Annual Bankruptcy Ethics Symposium
On December 13, 2013, the Los Angeles chapter of the Federal Bar Association held the 10th Annual Bankruptcy Ethics Symposium at the Edward R. Roybal Federal Building and U.S. Courthouse in Los Angeles. Featured speakers included Judges Ernest M. Robles and Deborah J. Saltzman, along with attorneys Gillian N. Brown, J. Scott Bovitz, M. Erik Clark, Christie L. Cronenweth, Evan A. Jenness, Stella A. Havkin, David W. Meadows, and David A. Tilem.
Judge Robles and attorneys Cronenweth, Tilem, Clark, and Brown presented “Pre-Bankruptcy Planning: 20 Shades of Gray,” a review of the rules in federal and California state law that govern bankruptcy attorneys’ conduct. Judge Deborah J. Saltzman and attorneys Bovitz and Meadows presented “Technology Tips and Trapdoors.” After a brief review of sections of the Court’s new Strategic Plan that addressed technology, the panel discussed a number of IT-related issues. The morning session also included a conversation about ethics with attorney Jenness. In the afternoon, two optional presentations followed: “Substance Abuse” with Dr. Alex Yufik of the State Bar of California and “Elimination of Bias” with attorneys Kenneth D. Sulzer and Julia Brodsky.
Clerk's Office Staff Facilitates Bankruptcy Basics
On December 10, 2013, Clerk’s Office staff members Sharon Sampson and Sabrina Palacio-Garcia participated as facilitators in the Bankruptcy Basics program presented by Public Counsel, co-sponsored by the Court and Central District Consumer Bankruptcy Attorney Association. The topics presented included “How to Register for CM/ECF” and “The Top 10 Filing Errors.” The Bankruptcy Basics Program was well-received by its attendees.
Community Outreach
In 2013, the Court continued to reach out to the community through educational initiatives aimed at increasing public understanding, trust, and confidence in the federal court system.
Central District Hosts Federal Court Power Lunches for Students
The Court hosted Federal Court Power Lunches at the Los Angeles Division for New Designs Charter School and Whitney High School on March 15 and December 13, 2013, respectively. The Federal Court Power Lunch program is designed for high school students to visit the courthouse to meet judges and lawyers and learn about the law and the legal profession.
On March 15, WilmerHale and the Women Lawyers Association of Los Angeles sponsored the Federal Court Power Lunch for New Designs Charter School. Participants included approximately 30 students; Chief Bankruptcy Judge Peter H. Carroll; Bankruptcy Judges Ernest M. Robles, Sandra R. Klein, Neil W. Bason, and Mark D. Houle; District Judges Dale S. Fischer and Philip S. Gutierrez; Chief Magistrate Judge Suzanne H. Segal; Magistrate Judge Jacqueline Chooljian; Los Angeles Court Commissioner Nicole Bershon; Keith Higginbotham, Esq.; Assistant U.S. Attorneys; Deputy Federal Public Defenders; Law Clerks Stephanie Rettier and Jared Ahern; Executive Officer/Clerk of Court Kathleen J. Campbell; and members of the Clerk’s Office staff.
The theme of the lunch was overcoming adversity and fear, and “dreaming big.” Judge Klein began the program by introducing the guest speakers, U.S. Attorney André Birotte, Jr. and Bankruptcy Judge Houle. U.S. Attorney Birotte and Judge Houle spoke about their backgrounds and achievements despite challenges and adversity. District Judge Gutierrez and Chief Magistrate Judge Segal provided the students with information about their backgrounds and noted challenges that they faced in their personal and professional lives.
On December 13, the South Asian Bar Association of Southern California (SABA) sponsored the Federal Court Power Lunch for Whitney High School. In addition to approximately 50 students, participants included Ninth Circuit Judge Jacqueline H. Nguyen; Bankruptcy Judge Sandra R. Klein; Chief Magistrate Judge Suzanne H. Segal; Magistrate Judges Alka Sagar and Michael R. Wilner; Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Holly J. Fujie; U.S. Attorney André Birotte, Jr.; Assistant Ninth Circuit Executive David Madden; UCLA Ann C. Rosenfield Fellow Julie Pollock; attorneys from the Offices of the U.S. Attorneys, Office of the Federal Public Defender, and Federal Bureau of Prisons; Law Clerks Stephanie Rettier and Razmig Izakelian; Executive Officer/Clerk of Court Kathleen J. Campbell; and Clerk’s Office staff. Judge Nguyen kicked off the event and discussed her background, “dreaming big,” and never letting obstacles get in her way. Judge Segal explained what magistrate judges do and what led her to a career in law. Judge Sagar provided information about her family, background, and career.
Both Federal Court Power Lunches discussed general legal topics to prepare the students for a game of “Legal Jeopardy.” Legal Jeopardy, which is played like a traditional game of Jeopardy, has categories including “Judges and Lawyers,” “Trials,” “Bills of Rights,” “Think Like a Lawyer,” and “Who’s Who in the Courtroom.” The students had a great time answering the questions and learning about the law and the legal profession.
Summit View School Visits San Fernando Valley Division
On March 20, 2013, approximately 20 students from Summit View School visited the San Fernando Valley Division in Woodland Hills. Summit View School offers comprehensive elementary, middle, and secondary school programs for students with learning differences. Judges Alan M. Ahart and Maureen A. Tighe provided an educational session on Credit Abuse Resistance Education (CARE). The interactive session helped the students find out how much they knew about finances. Also, the U.S. Probation Office explained the duties of a probation officer and how the officers’ services help the community. The speakers provided hands-on experience, letting the students try on bulletproof vests and ankle bracelets, and even performing mock testing for drugs.
People v. Goldilocks Mock Trial
In January and June 2013, the San Fernando Valley Division hosted students from Faith Baptist Elementary School and Chime Elementary School. The students participated in the Court’s People v. Goldilocks mock trial, hosted by Judge Maureen A. Tighe. With the assistance of the Clerk’s Office staff, the same mock trial was held simultaneously in three Maureen A. Tighe courtrooms. After the trial, all of the students were given a chance to sit on the bench, hold the judge’s gavel, and take a picture with Judge Tighe. The students enjoyed the experience of being in a real courtroom and being able to play the roles of defendant, plaintiff, juror, and, of course, judge.
Court Selects UCLA Ann C. Rosenfield Fellow to Address Elderly Issues in Bankruptcy
At the 2012 Ninth Circuit Judicial Conference, Judges Sandra R. Klein, Maureen A. Tighe, Erithe A. Smith, and Executive Officer/Clerk of Court Kathleen J. Campbell spoke to UCLA Field Education Liaison Doreen Klee about the unique challenges facing older Americans in bankruptcy. Judges Klein and Tighe and Executive Officer/Clerk of Court Campbell followed up with UCLA faculty and developed a grant application for the UCLA Ann C. Rosenfield Fellow to support the Court’s effort to address an increasing percentage of elderly bankruptcy filers. From a competitive applicant pool, the Court was one of four organizations selected to host a fellow for the 2013-2014 academic year, along with the L.A. Department of Mental Health, United Way, and the Council for Watershed Health.
UCLA’s Luskin School of Public Affairs describes the Ann C. Rosenfield Fellowship as a “high-level apprenticeship program for exceptional public policy, social welfare, and urban planning graduate students.” After interviewing the highly qualified final applicants, Judge Klein and Executive Officer/Clerk of Court Campbell selected Julie Pollock as the Court’s UCLA Ann C. Rosenfield Fellow.
Ms. Pollock, who is earning her Master’s Degree in Social Welfare, joined the Court in June. She is currently working with pro bono organizations serving the Court district-wide to research and design material highlighting the increasingly insecure financial landscape in which older Americans find themselves. Other projects in the works include developing educational materials about financial elder abuse for judges creating asset inventories of resources for older adults, developing financial education seminars to address foreclosure and reverse mortgage fraud, and providing limited case management assistance to older debtors.
Earle Hagen Memorial Golf/Tennis Tournament
On September 30, 2013, Public Counsel and the Central District Consumer Bankruptcy Attorney Association hosted the Earle Hagen Memorial Golf and Tennis Tournament at the Porter Valley Country Club in Northridge. A check in the amount of $29,231.15 was presented at the Calvin Ashland Awards Dinner on November 14, 2013. All proceeds from the fundraiser are used to support the Public Counsel Law Center and its Debtor Assistance Project.
Tenth Annual Run for Justice
On March 16, 2013, Public Counsel held its 10th annual “Run for Justice” 5K run/walk in conjunction with the LA Marathon. Judge Maureen A. Tighe participated in the event, joined by five chambers and Clerk’s Office staff members from the Los Angeles and San Fernando Valley divisions. Funds raised from the “Run for Justice” enable Public Counsel to continue to assist the most vulnerable members of society, including abused and abandoned children, foster care youth, homeless families, the elderly, veterans, victims of domestic violence, refugees fleeing torture, and nonprofit organizations.
Second Annual 5K Run/Walk for DAP
On April 27, 2013, the Second Annual Leslie Cohen Law 5K Run/Walk was held in Santa Monica to benefit Public Counsel’s Debtor Assistance Project (DAP). The event raised $7,500 for the pro bono legal assistance program. Bankruptcy Judges Maureen A. Tighe and Sandra R. Klein and Chapter 13 Trustee Kathy Dockery were among the 300 participants.
Riverside Wins CFC Award
On February 12, 2013, members of the Combined Federal Campaign (CFC) hosted a luncheon at the Brea Community Center for keyworkers, the federal employees who volunteer to represent CFC’s fundraising efforts in their workplaces. At the luncheon, awards were presented to the agencies that had raised the most money and agencies that had improved donations from the previous year. The Riverside Division received a Bronze Award for increasing contributions by over 21 percent from 2012.
Combined Federal Campaign Participation
In 2013, the Court continued to raise money through employee participation in and contributions to the Combined Federal Campaign (CFC), which promotes and supports philanthropy through its employee-focused, cost-efficient, and effective programs. CFC is the world’s largest and most successful annual workplace charity campaign.
Pledges support eligible nonprofit organizations that provide health and human service benefits throughout the world. With a grand total of $29,535, CFC contributions by divisions were as follows: Los Angeles, $18,605; San Fernando Valley, $5,019; Riverside, $3,118; Santa Barbara, $400; and Santa Ana, $2,393.
Center of Excellence for Employee Engagement Makes Charitable Contributions
In 2013, the Court’s Center of Excellence for Employee Engagement sponsored two charitable events. From May 20 to May 31, the Center of Excellence sponsored a clothing drive to benefit the Union Rescue Mission, a Los Angeles-based organization that serves homeless men, women, and children in the community. The clothing drive was a rousing success with over 50 bags donated by court employees.
In addition, the Center of Excellence sponsored a holiday food drive. Participants in all five divisions joined together to donate nonperishable food items to organizations approved by the Combined Federal Campaign.
Snowman Banner Toy Drive
For the ninth year in a row, the Riverside Division participated in the Riverside County Department of Mental Health Snowflake Banner Toy Drive program. Each year, a snowman banner is delivered to the division with white snowflakes. Each snowflake represents a child ranging in age from two to 17 years old and includes a request for a gift the child would like to receive. Staff members in Riverside purchased many gifts based on children’s wishes.
ONEgeneration Senior Holiday Project
In December 2013, Clerk’s Office staff members from the San Fernando Valley Division collected and donated gifts to ONEgeneration’s annual Holiday SHARE (Sending Help and Real Essentials) project. ONEgeneration is a charitable organization located in the San Fernando Valley that serves low-income seniors and families, providing meals, scholarships, social services, and other programs. President and CEO Judy Hamilton-Cantu personally expressed her gratitude for the Court’s continued generosity and participation.